What to do if your Challenges Aren't Converting
PT Distinction
PowerfulFlexibleQuality

What to do if your Challenges Aren't Converting

by Tim Saye | Mar 13, 2018


You run an online challenge, get good engagement, clients follow your challenge and get great results. Then comes the part where you convert them in to your long term packages and they all decide they can go it alone and get long term results without you. What went wrong?...


While it would be great if all clients could get long term results after doing a 3 week challenge the statistics (and the laws of diminishing returns) prove this is not the case for most people.

...This post looks at the things you may have missed and how you ensure your challenge members convert in to your long term packages to get long term results.


Whenever you do a challenge, a trial or any form of client generation you should always think about dropping a breadcrumb trail:


1 - Make sure everybody knows you have long term coaching that you will sell them at the end of the challenge. I know it sounds obvious but make this clear and make sure people know about it from day 1.


2 - Drop in regular stories and testimonials from your long term clients. Tag them in your challenge groups as well if you can so that they can chat to your current challengers.

3 - Talk about the laws of diminishing returns and why it's so important to consistently work on new habits and adjust the training you do to keep getting results. Even though very few people will click them I would drop in some links to scientific studies here just as subtle proof.

4 - Drop in a couple of stories of clients that did brilliantly on their challenge, who loved how easy it was and thought they could go it alone. Sadly 3 months later they're back to square one.... I would even say on these that this message is here to ensure you don't make the same mistake that set these guys back 4 months.

As people are naturally programmed to follow what they see everyone else doing I would always add to these messages that luckily most people join the long term package and get amazing results like... (then enter another long term clients result!). The reason for this is that you want the social proof to indicate that most people join your long term package and not to indicate that lots of people go it alone.

Most people really do follow the crowd, think about how you chose a restaurant. If you see one that's packed and one that's empty, even if you know very little else about the two restaurants you assume the busy one is better and chose that one.

5 - Have a round up video at the end of the challenge.

Your round up video should go a little like this;

- This is what we have done.
> these are the results everyone got
> This is why you all got great results
> This is why doing the same thing will stop bringing you results soon
> This is how to get long term results... (If you want to take away the guesswork of getting long term results then join my program here .... add a link to sign up!) Just like these guys did....

(if you have a video montage of successful clients talking about how amazing your program is and how it changed their lives then add it in here.... If not then try to make one!

To ensure your clients get it I would send this video through the app messenger in the worlds premier online personal training software.

6 - Have a compelling offer that encourages people to sign up now rather than some time later.

Good options for this include:

- A special discount available for all challengers for 24 hours after the challenge finishes,
A special prize draw with an awesome prize (maybe a top of the range tablet to follow their coaching on, or a Spa/ beach weekend away to feel great in their new body) where you will pick out a winner from all people that sign up before the draw.

- Have a limited number of spaces available in your long term packages so if you don't sign up now you may not get a place.

- The most effective strategy to get people to sign up now though is simply to have a date after which they can't sign up until you open the doors to new members again.

Chose one method, make sure it's genuine, that you're true to your word and go with it.


Once you have these things in place your conversion rates should be very high and you should fill your long term packages nicely.

With that said you should always add every past challenger in to an email group, and your Facebook group if you have one and keep following up with great content and occasional offers to join your services again.


This post came from a discussion in our Facebook Group started by the awesome Ged O'Hara.
April 2018
How to be the best paid Trainer in Your gym
How to Stand out From BeachBody on Demand
How to Stay Productive and Have a Life when your Online Business Grows
March 2018
Easily Communicate with Clients, Past Clients and Prospects
Look Inside The PT Distinction Online Trainer University
This Months New Online Personal Training Exercises
The PT Distinction University is Live
What to do if your Challenges Aren't Converting
1-1 Online Personal Training Packages
3 Ways to Collect Reviews and Testimonials
February 2018
2 easy ways to get Online Clients if you Train People in Person
Hybrid - A Big Step to Online Personal Training
The Benefits of Being a Face To Face Trainer Before Going Online
A Simple way to Write an Effective Homepage
Big List of Online Training Exercises Added
Online Personal Training Exercises - Day 6
Todays New Exercises
New Exercises for Online Personal Training - Day 4
New Exercises Added Every Day - Day 3
New Exercises Every Day - Day 2
January 2018
New Exercises Added
Integrating Free Booking Software to PT Distinction
Linking My Fitness Pal to PT Distinction
The role of Automated Online Training in 2018
How to Reset your Email Integration
How to copy Sections of your Workouts
Integrating PT Distinction in to your Website
4 Simple Automated Emails That Will Dramatically Boost Your Online Sales
Jon Goodman - How to Catch a Lucky Break
December 2017
Free Trials that get Paying Clients on a Regular Basis
Tracking Your Clients Extra Activity
Happy Christmas
Odd Tweak That can Double Your Clients Adherence to Online Training
The easy way Successful Trainers can Start Online.
Demo: Custom iOS App Branding Since Apples Changes
Less is More Coaching for Amazing Results
The Advert Every Online Trainer Should Have
Why you Should Never use YouTube for Exercise Videos
November 2017
Bring back past Online Training Clients with Simple Follow Up
Facebook Ads for Online Trainers – Stage Two
Facebook Ads for Online Personal Trainers – Stage One
12 Steps to Rank Videos High on YouTube
Sample Programs – A great way to get 1-1 Online Clients
Video: Scheduling Programs and Editing Acute Variables
7 Tips if you Struggle to get Online Clients
List of New Exercises Added to PT Distinction
October 2017
The Power of PTD Groups for Individualised Coaching
The Power of Online Training Testimonials
Improvement to Exercise Search on PT Distinction
New Exercises Coming Soon.
Exercise Technique Coaching for Online Clients
Review - MyZone Vs Fitbit
Video: Communicate Easily with Clients on PT Distinction
Coaching Tools on PT Distinction
Create and Explain any Type of Program in Minutes
September 2017
Turning Prospects in to Long Term Clients (lessons from real life)
New Feature: Fitbit Integration
Demo Video: Online Group Training Done Properly
What Goes in to Great Group Online Training?
Changes to Adherence Percentages on PT Distinction
New Feature: MyZone Integration
How to Find any Exercise Quickly on PT Distinction
Advertising Checklist for Online Personal Trainers
Content that Brings you Online Personal Training Clients
August 2017
How many Online Personal Training Clients do you need?
Perfect Online Personal Training Packages and Prices
Live Q & A With Tim and Ash
New Exercises Added to PT Distinction
The New Instant Messenger
Video Check-ins to Easily Communicate with your Clients
The Online Personal Trainer Success Template
The Power of PTD Groups
July 2017
What to Automate when Training Bespoke Online Clients
3 Stages of an Online Fitness Business
You are the Product of the 5 People you Spend the most time with – A semi Alternative view.
The Online Personal Training Super System
How To Craft A Compelling Online Training Guarantee
Live Event - Online Personal Training Success
How to Get Started and Create Perfect Very Quickly
How to get 2-10 Online Training Clients a day from Facebook
How to set up Automated sign ups on your Website.
June 2017
PT Distinction Webinars - Linh Trinh on Filling your Challenges and Flagship Programs
3 Things That Separate Very Successful Online Personal Trainers From the Rest
Import Button Added to Google Sheets Integration
Google Sheets Integration
PT Distinction Webinars - Jon Goodman on All Things Online Personal Training
Webinar Recording - AJ Mihrzad, 5 steps to a Substantial Online Business
12 Steps to Maximise Conversions from Online Challenges
Fundamentals to Online Transformations
May 2017
Running Your Own Facebook Group – The Pros and Cons
100 Percent Online Hybrid Training
Online Personal Training Business in a Box With Sukh Sidhu
3 Posts That Will Turn Viewers Into Clients of Great Trainers
5 Habits to Build a Great Online Training Business
How to use the Messaging Centre to Maximise your Clients Results and Triple Conversions into your Long-term Services.
Monster Upgrade - PT Distinction Messaging Centre
Create Programs with Different Weight and Reps for Each Set of an Exercise
April 2017
Set Up and Automate Your Online Challenges in Minutes
How to Follow up With Past and Potential Online Personal Training Clients to Triple Your Conversions
Positioning Free Trials and Challenges to Make Your Online Training Successful
An Easy Way to Get Online Personal Training Clients While Helping Lots of People
How to Describe Hybrid Training to Your Clients
3 Major Benefits to Clients of Online Coaching
PTD Time Savers - Using a Warm Up For Multiple Workouts
Tracking Your Clients Daily Activity
Create Great Online Personal Training Content in Minutes
How to Get New Online Clients by Taking Screenshots!
Simple Sales Funnels For Online Trainers
How to Put Assessments into Your Clients Apps
March 2017
4 Simple Steps to Coach 100+ Online Clients Without any Staff
Setting up Your Automated Packages to Start on Monday
Keeping Your Browser up to Date For Perfect Software Results
The Value in Writing Your Goals and Having Accountability
How to Get Hybrid and Online Training Clients When You Work in a Gym
Using LinkedIn to Get New Clients Every Month
Creating Custom Forms and Questionaires
Gifts are important, but most trainers suck at giving gifts - By Jon Goodman
February 2017
The Easiest Way to Package Hybrid Model Coaching
What Can Online Personal Trainers Learn From Self Made Billionaires?
Habit Coaching and Tracking on PT Distinction
New Program/ Workout Builder is Live!!!
What Is The Hybrid Training Model?
Creating a Flagship Program on PT Distinction
Pros and Cons of Online Vs Face to Face Pt 2 - Money and Competition
The Pros and Cons of a Successful Online Business Compared to Being a Face to Face Personal Trainer – Part One; Work and Holidays
January 2017
A Look Inside Our New Program Builder
What Happens When Your Client Records Something in Your Personal Training App
4 Ways To Create The Time To Build a Great Online Training Business
Adding Forms and Questionnaires and Getting Them Signed Online
Update: Tweak to Make Your Challenges and Flagship Products Run Super Smooth
Improvement to Program Builder- Exercise Thumbnails
December 2016
Are Realistic Goals Stifling Your Online Business and Causing You Stress?
How to Create Unlimited Content - Big Key to Your Success
Using Your App With Face to Face Training Clients
How To Easily Deliver High End Online Personal Training And Coaching
3 Monthly Habits That Will Help You Grow Your Online Training Business
6 Weekly Habits To Grow A Big Online Training Business
The Only Systems That Will Make You A Successful Online Trainer/ Coach
Why Many Personal Trainers Fail and How to Learn From Their Mistakes
November 2016
Improvements to Custom Exercises
Super Simple Online Personal Training
Facebook Ads Strategy That Gets Online Personal Training Clinets
5 Reasons To Start Sending Newsletters
October 2016
Creating an Online Fitness Challenge That Gets Results
Huge New Feature - The Online Personal Training Success Map
Common Traits of The Most Successful Online Personal Trainers
Upgrade: The Best Scheduling and Alerts System in the Online Training World!
September 2016
What Your Coaching Looks Like For Your Clients
Sneak Peak Inside Our New Calendar And Alerts System
How to Motivate Your Clients When They Aren't With You
How to use LinkedIn like a pro
August 2016
How To Get Your First 1000 Likes on Facebook
If You Sign Up New Clients Over The Phone Do This
Lead Generation Ideas for FitPros
How To Use Facebook Live On Your Desktop
July 2016
Useful Tools For Any Online Personal Trainer
Video: Sign Clients Up Directly From Facebook
Upgrade - Create Sales Funnels and Get Clients In Minutes
Upgrade - Add Names To Group Emails and Autoresponders
How To Get Clients From Facebook Groups
The Basics of Snapchat
June 2016
The Simple Way To Get Your First 5-10 Online Clients Without Spending a $
Upgrade; Schedule Online Coaching Videos, Recipes, Coaching Documents, Forms and Questionaires.
New Upgrade - Add Unlimited Email Subscribers For Free
Email Marketing Guide
How to Get the Best out of Instagram
5 Reasons Forbes.com Suggest All Small Businesses Should Have Their Own App
A Look Inside Your 100% Branded Personal Training Apps
NEW FEATURE - Your Own App in Android and Apple Stores
May 2016
How To Get Online Personal Training Clients Using Free Trials
How to create a massive, enjoyable, sustainable online business that positions you as the expert and makes you happy every day.
Are Facebook Groups Good For Your Online Training Business?
How You Can Use Facebook Live To Attract Online Clients
April 2016
The Simple Method for Writing A Really Effective Sales Page
How to Make Your Client Sorry They Ever Left You!
How To Get More Online Training Clients
March 2016
Recording Habits and Results Next to Goals
Want to See Our Online Personal Training Apps?
Paul Mort on Selling Online Personal Training
Upcoming Interview - Mr Paul Mort
February 2016
Main Dashboard Overview
Improvement - Adding Custom Exercises with Your Custom Results Charting Just Got Easy!
Upgrade: Recording and Charting Assessment Results Just Got A Lot Better!
December 2015
Janak Patel Interview - How You Can Become a Successful Online Personal Trainer and Create The lifestyle You Want
November 2015
Expert Interview Number 2 Is Coming Soon!
Update: New Android App Is Live
Video: Give or Schedule Assessments to Multiple Clients in Seconds
Quick Video: Find Any Exercise or Verities of Exercises Fast
October 2015
Upcoming Improvements to PT Distinction
Downloading your videos from YouTube to Put on PT Distinction
Video: How You Add Tracking and Charting to Your Custom Exercises
September 2015
Meal Plans
Tim Drummond Interview - How You Become a High End Online Personal Trainer
New Look Is Live!
August 2015
Updates to PT Distinction
July 2015
Video: Adding Custom Exercises in Seconds
Helping You To Get More Clients
Video: Creating and Using Templates
Something Free To Impress Your Face to Face Clients With
June 2015
Automated Marketing Method No. 2 - Using Pinterest as a Search Engine
10 Videos That Every Personal Trainer Should Make
May 2015
Video: How I Use The Groups System to Save Time on All of My Coaching Packages
Video - Getting Clients From YouTube + A Massive Opportunity!
Automated Marketing Roadmap
Set and Forget Marketing For Your Fitness Business (proven to work!)
Video Demo; The Most Flexible Results Tracking and Charting System in The World
April 2015
Tracking and Charting System is Up and Live!
Results Tracking With Pretty Graphs
Video: How to Make a High Quality, Fully Automated Online Coaching Product in Under An Hour
Video: How to Set Up Retargeting Adverts and Convert More Website Visitors in to Clients.
Apple App
March 2015
Follow Along Video - How to take direct debit payments online
Save Loads of Time by Using Groups in PT Distinction
Completely Customise PTD - Follow Along Video
Video: Adding Before and After Photos
Follow along video - How to do a complete assessment online
The Most Important Step in Becoming an Online Personal Trainer
How to Make Perfect Programs For Online Personal Training Clients
February 2015
How to Motivate Your Online Personal Training Clients
How to Get Online Clients For Free
Apple App
December 2014
New App!
Updates to Our Online Personal Training Software
5 Steps to Being a Successful Online Trainer
November 2014
The Value of Recipes For Your Clients
How to Make Your Clients Happy to Pay Direct Debits
The Power of Groups
The Future of Fitness
We Had a Few Issues... Sorted Now
October 2014
PT Distinction 2.0 is Live!!
Version 2.0 is Finally Here!!
September 2014
Set Up Direct Debits
August 2014
Let The World See How Good You Are
Upgrade: Integrate PTD in to Your Own Website
Make August Your Best Month Online
July 2014
How to Do a Quality Online Assessment Via Skype
PTD FAQs
Get Clients From (nearly!) All of Your Consultations